My Slice of the Pie Pizzeria Menu (Update 2025)
Welcome to My Slice of the Pie Pizzeria, where culinary innovation meets comfort food in the heart of Phoenix! At this vibrant eatery, pizza lovers can indulge in creative specialty pizzas like the Sonoran Pizza and the Al Pastor, merging Southwestern flavors with classic Italian roots. With gluten-free options and build-your-own choices, everyone can find something to satisfy their cravings.
The menu goes beyond pizza, featuring mouthwatering wings that range from Sweet & Sassy to spicy Pia y Habanero, each boasting unique flavors. Coupled with inviting lunch specials and hearty portions, My Slice of the Pie is perfect for families and groups, whether dining in or enjoying the outdoor seating. The lively atmosphere is complemented by friendly service, ensuring that every visit leaves you with a smile.
Experience the magic of pizza at 3724 E Indian School Rd—you won’t regret it!
Wings
Sweet & Sassy Wings
Mild heat. Carolina gold base.
BBQ Mole Wings
Mild heat. BBQ forward with mole influences.
Old School Frankies Hot Wings
Medium heat. Franks buffalo medium sauce.
Pia y Habanero Wings
Hot. Sweet and flavorful front with back end spiced kick.
Lemon Pepper
Garlic Parmesan
Sonoran Pizza
Southwest sauce, mozzarella, roma tomato, diced green chili, roasted corn, red onion, fresh garlic, queso fresco, cilantro, and cotija.
The Supreme Being Pizza
House-made Sauce, Four Cheese Blend, Mushroom, Pepperoni, Sausage, Green Bell Pepper, Red Onion, Black Olive, Fresh Garlic, Bacon, Oregano.
El Blanco
Roasted jalapeo garlic olive oil, four cheese blend, asadero, roma tomato, fire-roasted artichoke, roasted red pepper, ricotta, fresh garlic, fresh basil, and cotija.
Al Pastor What Pizza
Southwest Sauce, Mozzarella, Al Pastor, Red Onion, Grilled Pineapple, Cilantro, Cotija, Fire Roasted Jalapeno Puree.
You Gotta Carne Asada
Southwest sauce, fresh garlic, roma tomato, chargrilled carne asada, red onion, mozzarella, fire-roasted tomato salsa, avocado puree, crema, cilantro, and cotija.
El Rey Pizza
Southwest sauce, mozzarella, asadero, pollo asado, Schreiner's chorizo, diced green chili red onion, roasted com, fresh garlic, cilantro, and cotija.
The Veg Pizza
House-made sauce, four cheese blend, mushroom, green bell pepper, roma tomato red onion, fresh garlic, fresh basil, ricotta, and oregano.
The Marg
Roma Tomato, Fresh Mozzarella, Fresh Basil. Presto!
Barb-Ba-Que-Onda Pizza
House made bbq mole sauce, mozzarella, pollo asado, roasted jalapeno, red onion, spiced crema, cilantro, cotija.
Specialty Pizzas
Build Your Own Pizza
18" Traditional NY Style Pizza
14" Traditional NY Style Pizza
12" Traditional NY Style Pizza
12" Gluten Free
New York GLUTEN FREE Thin Crust, House Red Sauce, Mozzarella Cheese and Oregano. A classic.
Against Pasta
Ciao Bella! Romaine, Red Onion, Cucumber, Black Olive, Green Bell Pepper, Roasted Artichoke, Provolone and Salami with Italian Dressing.
Caesar Salad
The Casa
Salads
Appetizers
Elote Flatbread
Roasted jalapeo garlic olive oil, minced garlic, mayonnaise, white sweet corn, cotija cheese, and spiced crema with tajin (citrus seasoning).
Housemade Meatballs
14 ingredient House made meatballs baked to perfection. Served in a spiced marinara. Topped with parmesan. (Melted mozzarella optional.)
Garlic Cheese Bread
Melted Mozzarella, House Roasted Garlic oven baked on top our homemade pizza dough. Finished with House Roasted Jalapeno Garlic Oil and Oregano.
Garlic Bread Sticks
House Roasted Garlic oven baked on top our homemade pizza dough. Finished with House Roasted Jalapeno Garlic Oil and Oregano. Perfect size for dipping and sharing!
Spaghetti
NY Cheesecake Slice
Dessert
Sandwiches
The Meatball
Homemade Meatballs, Marinara and Melted Provolone.
Italian Deli
Salami, Pepperoni, Ham, Provolone, Roasted Red Pepper, Peppercini, Red Onion and Italian Dressing